Author, Philosopher, Theologian

Author: CL

  • Property as a Civil Right?

    Property as a Civil Right?

    (1) Property means freedom

    (2) Property sets a boundary

    (3) The (fair) distribution of property remains controversial

    (4) Moral justifications for the distribution of property are difficult – at least from a liberal perspective

    (5) Distributed property is the guarantee of plurality

    6) Property has a dual character

    (7) As a contract, property can be virtualized

    (8) Virtualization alienates the owner from his owned property

    (9) Virtualization allows for a merciful increase in ownership

    (10) Virtual property finds its limit in reality

    (11) Virtual property requires its realisation

    (12) Property is not an end in itself, and neither is freedom

    One Final Thought


    [1] For the written version, the lecture has been supplemented with references to sources and adapted in some places for easier readability. Most of the citations have been translated from German by the author. Further texts by the author can be found at www.carstenlotz.de.

    [2] Marx, Karl. Manifesto of the Communist Party. Dietz Verlag, 1974, Part II.

    [3] Johann Gottlieb Fichte. Basis des Naturrecht nach Principien der Wissenschaftslehre, in: ibid., Sämtliche Werke, ed. by Immanuel Hermann Fichte, Berlin 1971, vol. 3, § 11, p. 117.

    [4] Jean-Jacques Rousseau. Abhandlung über die Ungleichheit. UTB 2008, 173.

    [5] Kant, Immanuel. Foundation of the Metaphysics of Morals. Berlin: Edition of the Prussian Academy of Sciences, “Metaphysical Foundations of Law”, I §15.

    [6] See: Friedman, Milton, und Rose D. Friedman. Capitalism and Freedom. 40th Anniversary Edition. University of Chicago Press, 1982, Chapter  II.

    [7] Hayek, Friedrich A. von. The constitution of liberty: the definitive edition. The collected works of F. A. Hayek, v. 17. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2011, Chapter  6.7. Eigene Übersetzung.

    [8] See: Friedman, Capitalism and Freedom, Chapter  X.

    [9] Hayek, Friedrich A. von. The Road to Serfdom: With the Intellectuals and Socialism. Combined edition, First published. Occasional Paper 136. London: iea, The Institute of Economic Affairs, 2005, Kapitel 8.

    [10] Ibidem.

    [11] Marx. Manifesto of the Communist Party, Part II.

    [12] Fichte, Johann Gottlieb, and Richard Schottky. Rechtslehre. Hamburg: Felix Meiner Verlag, 2017, Part Two, chap. 3.1.

    [13] See z.B.: Friedman, Capitalism and Freedom, Chapter  X.

    [14] See: Berle, Adolf A., und Gardiner C. Means. The modern corporation and private property. New Brunswick, N.J., U.S.A: Transaction Publishers, 1991.

    [15] Burnham, James. The managerial revolution: what is happening in the world. London: Putnam and Company, 1942, Chapter  7.

    [16] Burnham. The managerial revolution, Chapter  8.

    [17] See Friedman, Milton. „A Friedman doctrine‐- The Social Responsibility Of Business Is to Increase Its Profits“. New York Times, 13. September 1970.

    [18] Fisher, Irving. The Theory of Interest: As Determined by Impatience to Spend Income and Opportunity to Invest It. New York, NY : Macmillan, 1930, Chapter  IX, §3.

    [19] See: Achleitner, Ann-Kristin, Reiner Braun, Nico Engel, Christian Figge, und Florian Tappeiner. „Value Creation Drivers in Private Equity Buyouts: Empirical Evidence from Europe“. The Journal of Private Equity 13, Nr. 2 (2010): 17–27.

    [20] Hayek. The constitution of liberty, Chapter  5.7.

    [21] See: McKinsey Global Institute. „Global Balance Sheet: The future of wealth and growth hangs in the balance“, Mai 2023.

    [22] https://imaa-institute.org/mergers-and-acquisitions-statistics/

    [23] Hayek. The constitution of liberty, Chapter  1.7.

    [24] Hayek. The constitution of liberty, Chapter  8.6.

    [25] Hayek, Friedrich A. von. The Road to Serfdom, Chapter  8.

    [26] Hayek. The constitution of liberty, Chapter  5.5.

    [27] Hayek, Friedrich A. von. The Road to Serfdom, Chapter  8.

    [28] See: https://www.taxjustice.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/Price_of_Offshore_Revisited_120722.pdf

    [29] See: Credit Suisse Research Institute, Hrsg. Global Wealth Report 2022.

  • The dialectic of liberalism

    The dialectic of liberalism

    Platzhalter – Titelbild einsetzen

    The dialectic of liberalism

    Almost 250 years ago, Immanuel Kant defined the Enlightenment as man’s emergence from his self-inflicted immaturity. Since then, liberalism as a philosophical, political and economic movement has invoked this individual maturity and has shaped Western societies and their economic systems. But its appeal is waning. Right-wing and populist forces are gaining strength in democracies; at the same time, totalitarian dictatorships are opening up their economies but not their societies. The popular equation “free economy = free society” is increasingly proving to be false.

    This comes as no surprise. As early as the 1950s, the German philosopher Theodor W. Adorno warned that the economic order would keep the majority of people in a state of immaturity even after the end of fascism. He was less concerned with concrete economic well-being and the lack of economic means for self-realisation. Rather, he saw the economic system as a form of coercion that stood in the way of the individual’s experience of autonomy. The broken promise of freedom and autonomy made people indifferent to democracy and susceptible to the promises of totalitarianism.

    Since Adorno’s diagnosis, this compulsion, we want to argue, has become fully apparent in society as an anonymous system – in the professional, private and political spheres – and is now, with the breakthrough of artificial intelligence, likely to jeopardise democracy in its very essence.

    The professional world has become anonymous and offers less and less of a social home. Formerly owner-managed shops – supermarkets, drugstores, DIY stores – have given way to branches of large nationwide or even international companies and have left the inner-city life. Processes, product ranges and workwear have been standardised. The responsible entrepreneur has been replaced by the branch manager who is controlled by KPIs. In large corporations, local structures have been replaced by functional ones. Cross-sectional tasks have been centralised, outsourced or offshored. Who used to be a colleague is now an external service provider and may be replaced tomorrow. And within one’s own workplace, agile teams, teleworking and flex offices are dissolving binding structures. Whoever comes to work becomes a cog in the wheel.

    Private life has become more complicated and economised. Thanks to the liberalisation of formerly public services, citizens now have to make more economic decisions than ever before. They can choose from hundreds of electricity, gas and telecommunications tariffs. They have to choose a health insurance company and, if possible, opt for some private pension plan. The situation is unmanageable. After signing the contract, people often discover that they have missed out on a special offer, not taken advantage of a retention or switching bonus or not cancelled a free additional offer in due time. 

    And politicians are also increasingly resorting to economic instruments to steer society: CO2 taxes and pollution-dependent lorry tolls, long-term tuition fees and education vouchers, cigarette and alcohol taxes, the list goes on. The state exerts economic pressure, which mainly reaches the lower classes; the wealthy have the financial means to buy their way out.

    The liberalisation of formerly public services and the targeted taxation of undesirable behaviour can be seen as liberal democracy’s response to the acceleration of modernity described by Hartmut Rosa: Where all aspects of life are continually accelerating, democratic decision-making and compromise-taking take too long. Economic logic is faster, but also more liberal, because it does not impose rules, but lets people decide how and where they spend their money.

    All these developments have brought us economic benefits: longer shop opening hours, a wider range of goods, cheaper products, fewer government bans. But they have also increased the coercive nature of an anonymous system. Today, it is difficult to find someone to assume responsibility. It always seems to be the anonymous market that we cannot escape. In 1984, the German Minister of Posts still had to answer to parliament for the 6-month waiting times for a telephone connection at the Lübeck telecommunications office. Today there is no longer such a minister; and the answer to the lack of fibre optic connections or poor network coverage is economic constraints and “the (failing) market”. Yet the market is proving effective in preventing unprofitable projects, however much they are politically desirable.

    Liberalism is blind to the fact that such market mechanisms can constitute coercion. Liberals conceive the market as the sum of the free decisions of responsible citizens. But while liberal societies continue to try and take the economy into their service, the international tech scene has long been thinking about a different future. Accelerationism is the name of a school of thought that believes humans are too imperfect and the institutional structure of the democratically organised state is too slow. The philosopher Nick Land propagates the organisation of society in the form of stock corporations with citizens as shareholders and strives for a comprehensively technologised and de-humanised economy.

    Since the breakthrough of Artificial Intelligence, this is within reach. The structural consequences for the relationship between business and society have so far been underestimated. In its detailed and differentiated statement on AI, the German Ethics Council analysed four fields in more detail –  medicine, education, public communication and opinion-forming as well as public administration – but mainly focused on individual applications. However, the fact that machines and algorithms take over individual processes or process steps in companies is nothing new; for example, a large part of stock exchange trading is already automated today, and the autopilot lands an aeroplane more smoothly than a human.

    What is new is the possibility of fully networking individual processes and automating the entire company, from purchasing and employee scheduling to sales. The Chinese company Netdragon Websoft replaced the CEO of its Fujian subsidiary with an artificial intelligence in August 2022 – albeit presumably as a PR stunt. What we are looking at is an independent software that can participate in economic activity as a company. This is not primarily about reducing costs, as the current discussion about job losses would have us believe. The far greater leverage of AI is to increase sales and margins; in short: we should all buy more and pay more.

    We will therefore probably see the first fully digital companies in the sale of simple contracts: electricity and gas, telephone and internet, banking and insurance services. The platforms have long been in place, the processes are digitalised and run on Amazon, Google and Microsoft servers in the cloud. At the moment, the last people are still working in customer service, in product development and in programming the processes. As soon as the computer can reliably communicate and programme independently, they too will be replaced. And as the computer always has all the relevant data available across our various needs, it can adapt its sales strategy in real time by analysing its human counterpart. As it doesn’t get tired even after eight, twelve or sixteen hours of use, it will become an irresistible salesperson and seducer. Gilles Deleuze’s metaphor of capitalism as a machine becomes reality.

    Do we need to redefine economic freedom in the face of new technological realities? – Liberalism rightly defends the freedom of the human entrepreneur. It is difficult to imagine a free society without free choice of profession and free entrepreneurship. The economist Friedrich August von Hayek went so far as to celebrate the economic society as the saviour of democracy from itself. Democracy has a tendency to become “inevitably egalitarian”, he wrote. With the legal fiction of the “legal person” (Article 19 of the German constitution), we even guarantee basic rights for companies and are prepared to weigh these up against the basic rights of humans. But would we also guarantee the fundamental rights of a company controlled by machines if it replaced a company controlled by humans? – Blindfolded, Justice will not see the difference.

    Enlightenment, which, as Kant said, requires “only freedom”, will not be enough. He still considered our immaturity to be self-inflicted through “laziness and cowardice”. Liberalism has come a long way with this thesis: We probably live today in the most prosperous and freest of all worlds. Kant was confident that in a free society, a few would start to think and thus enlighten the rest. But they will have a hard time against the machines and their art of seduction. We are becoming increasingly immature in the face of the machine. It knows more about us than we do ourselves, knows our pain thresholds when it wants us to work for it and our weak points when it wants to sell us something.

    If Adorno’s thesis that the experiences of coercion associated with the economic system give the right a boost is correct – and various current studies show correlations between dissatisfaction with democracy and the rejection of (economic) globalisation as well as the feeling of no longer belonging to society – then we need to think about how we can put people back in a position to experience maturity.

    We need to strengthen individual entrepreneurs over anonymous companies and give people the chance to work in an environment that allows them to experience autonomy.

    We need to push back the economic decisions in the private sector, which many people are unable to understand, and which create little value for society as a whole. Nobody needs the multitude of providers and tariffs for (former) public services of general interest.

    And in politics, we would have to dare to make decisions politically again instead of inventing a market mechanism and then waiting for the smartest and fastest to win in the new market and the less smart and less fast to call for subsidies and postponement.

    All of this would mean that our social prosperity would grow more slowly because we are slowing down economic dynamism. This makes issues of social justice more virulent than they are today and may strengthen left-wing groups, but it need not be harmful to liberal society, as it was primarily labour movements and the political left that contributed to the fall of totalitarian regimes, for example in Spain and Greece in the 1970s and in Eastern Europe at the end of the 1980s. The economy, on the other hand, will not rush to our aid against totalitarianism in case of doubt; it lives quite well with it in other parts of the world and has not stood out as a great resistance fighter in Germany’s past either.

    First publication: WirtschaftsWoche 35, 03/11/2023

  • The repair society

    The repair society

    Platzhalter – Titelbild einsetzen

    The repair society

    When Jean Baudrillard wrote about consumer society in 1970, he was looking back on almost 30 years of continuous economic growth. The French Trente Glorieuses, the glorious thirties, had quadrupled the GDP per capita and created unprecedented prosperity. The term “miracle”, as used by the Germans for their economic development, may never catch on in secular France, but the feeling was the same. Every year, more people could afford more. And things had to be bought and consumed. „Ich kauf mir was, Kaufen macht so viel Spaß! – I’ll buy something, buying is so much fun!“, the German singer Herbert Grönemeyer proclaimed in 1983 and succinctly expressed the self-image of the consuming citizen: “I already have everything, I want even more. Everything lasts forever, now we have to find something new.”

    Baudrillard recognized early on that it was exactly the permanence of things that stood in the way of the essence of consumption. It is not about buying and owning amenities, but about their “destruction”. Only when I consume what I have acquired, digest it or at least wear it out over time, does the machine of renewal keep going. Consumption becomes an end in itself: desire for desire’s sake. The consumer is not concerned with the necessities of life, but with abundance. It’s about that little bit more that you can afford: going to a restaurant, going on a holiday by the sea, the new car, even though the old one is still „okay”. That little bit more that you don’t need, but desire.

    The consumer society is not a society of scarcity, but a society of affluence. And its economy is less concerned with the efficient distribution of scarce goods than with the stimulation of consumption and desire: marketing and advertising are therefore gaining a crucial role in economic activity, so crucial that Google, Tencent and Facebook, three of the most valuable companies in the world, live almost exclusively on advertising revenue. The greatest success of marketing has been the radical acceleration of fashion and trends in almost all product groups: clothing, sports equipment, furniture, cars – everything ages faster because new trends are constantly being proclaimed. And the technical progress of the various “smart devices” and the associated apps is no longer much more than a fashion. For the average consumer, the difference between two generations of the same smartphone should be barely noticeable, with the advertised key performance figures not relating to some real world experience. He buys if he can, because he wants to buy. The protagonist of the consumer society is no longer homo economicus. His behavior can be better described as a game or as an addiction than as an optimization of one’s utility.

    Today, 50 years after Baudrillard and 40 years after Grönemeyer, consumption is still ongoing, even more than ever before, but the focus of society seems to be shifting at the same time, because we are experiencing that things don’t last forever. The society of the 1960s and 1970s was not only on a constant path of growth and prosperity, it was also largely spared from the repair of the existing: houses, roads, railways, power plants, telephone lines – everything was new at that time. Today, everything is getting old, and these things demand our attention, our time, and our money. The new built of basic infrastructure in particular is giving way to repair. It is often no longer a question of consuming or expanding, but of of re-novating the old that was built before our time.

    In Germany, according to the national Motorway Society, 400 motorway bridges have to be renewed every year. German Railways has announced a rehabilitation program of the most important railway corridors and stations, which will entail extensive closures and travel time extensions. Coal-fired power plants must be replaced by renewable energies and gas-fired plants with green hydrogen, and the power grids must be upgraded for electric cars and heat pumps. Moreover, the renovation rate of buildings must double, every year 2% – 2.5% of the existing stock: insulation of the roof and the walls, new windows and a new heating system. At the same time, our infrastructure must be prepared for the extreme weather events that are increasing with climate change: higher dams on rivers and more floodplains, more and larger rainwater retention basins in communities, a reduction in sealing and more green spaces in cities to reduce heating in summer.

    Crucially, all of this is happening without any real increase in prosperity. We already travel by car and train, have electricity and central heating and live comfortably. It’s no longer about the little bit more we could afford. It is about the defense of what has been achieved. It fits into the picture that in this situation we are also spending more money on national defense. The enemy of prosperity comes not only from within in the form of corrosion, wear and tear and the nature we provoke, but now again from the outside. The imminent better equipment of the Bundeswehr, the German army, is far from a “rearmament”. It is about replacing previous technology that is either no longer functional or outdated, or simply about filling up ammunition depots so that we don’t run out of ammunition after a few days in an emergency – and can effectively defend what we have. 

    The need for repairs to our infrastructure corresponds to the need for maintenance of ourselves. In Germany, the number of people in need of care is expected to rise from just under five million today to over six million in 2040, if you simply extrapolate today’s needs. We are getting older and older, and old people are more often in need of care. In addition, medical care is getting better and better, and more and more people are surviving more and more serious illnesses and will subsequently be in need of care. There will be at least one person in need of care in almost every family. Our view of the body will change, it will no longer be an object of desire, but an object of care.

    Fifty years ago, we already repaired things, but we mainly built new. And fifty years ago, the elderly were already being cared for, but at the same time many more children. The future was open. Today, the equation described by Baudrillard “growth = abundance = democratic participation of all” no longer works because we have too much to repair. If democracy is to continue to function, it needs a different narrative than that of consumption, growth and progress. The long-standing narrative of progress that has been the glue for modern societies is becoming fragile. The discussion of whether there is still progress is pointless; it is simply subjectively experienced by less and less: many no longer work at all, and those who work do not work on progress or innovation, but they repair and maintain.

    Who wants to keep society together and not watch this cohesion once again be organized by the national narrative and the demarcation from the outside world needs a different, more credible narrative, which this time cannot be a vision of a more prosperous future. It would have to build on the past, construct around elements of gratitude and responsibility for what has been achieved, which must be preserved for our (few) children. We would have to learn to be satisfied. To do this, we would have to leave behind the old consumer society and its marketing, which constantly persuades us that we need more. And to do this, we would also have to re-ask the question of distribution, since repairing and maintaining no longer grows the cake.

    First publication: WirtschaftsWoche 35, 25/08/2023